| TEAM | NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | GRAD YR | POS |
| Midwest Stars | Johnny McKay | Hudson | 2022 | IF, OF |
| Midwest Stars | Wyatt Prado | Hudson | 2022 | P, SS |
| Midwest Stars | Levi Belcher | Bethel Baptist Christian | 2022 | C |
| NEO Elite | Ryan Levan | Lake Catholic | 2022 | 2B |
| NEO Elite | Zac Tizzano | VASJ | 2022 | P, 1B, OF |
| NEO Elite | Sonny Iacampo | Gilmour Academy | 2021 | 1B, P |
| Players I Bulls | Zachary Gottlieb | Solon | 2022 | 1B, OF |
| Players I Bulls | Gavin McCoy | Twinsburg | 2022 | P,Ss,3b |
| Premier Ohio | Nate Kazimore | Brunswick | 2022 | OF |
| Premier Ohio | Anthony Bartiromo | Wadsworth | 2021 | P, C |
| Premier Ohio | Bryce Franczyk | Brunswick | 2021 | 1B |
| T3 Rays | Chase Myers | Avon | 2022 | P, 3B |
| T3 Rays | Jack Ritter | Amherst | 2021 | 1B |
| T3 Rays | Troy Sudbrook | Avon | 2022 | P, SS |
| TEAM | NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | GRAD YR | POS |
| Hurricanes Select | Joey Adler | St. Ignatius | 2022 | P |
| Hurricanes Select | Maks Maras | Brunswick | 2022 | 1B |
| Impact Longhorns Black | Dominic Perrine | Padua | 2022 | OF |
| Impact Longhorns Black | Shane Frimel | Brunswick | 2022 | MIF |
| Impact Longhorns Black | Matt Abbott | North Royalton | 2022 | P, 3B |
| Ohio Aces | Austin Kazmierczak | St. Ignatius | 2022 | 2B |
| Ohio Aces | Dylan Dotson | Buckeye | 2022 | P |
| Ohio Aces | Ty Moore | Wellington | 2022 | C |
| Ohio Longhorns | Connor Dunlap | Stow | 2022 | MIF |
| Ohio Longhorns | Jared Dunfee | Kent Roosevelt | 2022 | P, 1B |
| Release Baseball | Liam Shea | Strongsville | 2022 | P |
| Release Baseball | Ryan Miklich | St. Edward | 2022 | SS |
| Release Baseball | Tommy Harrison | St. Edward | 2022 | C, 3B |
| Stark Co. Terriers | Braden Broom | GlenOak | 2022 | 2B, SS |
| Stark Co. Terriers | Curt Taylor | Alliance | 2022 | P, 3B, 1B |
| TEAM | NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | GRAD YR | POS |
| Stingrays | Kyle Patrick | Strongsville | 2021 | MIF |
| T3 Rays | Zach Wheeler | Avon Lake | 2020 | P, IF |
| Stingrays | Zach Gaspar | Strongsville | 2021 | OF |
| Stingrays | Jacob Rocky | St. Ignatius | 2021 | P, 1B, OF |
| T3 Rays | Mike Motylewski | Avon Lake | 2020 | P, IF |
| Premier Ohio | Josh Bobey | Medina | 2021 | 1B, OF |
| T3 Rays | Ryan Starr | Avon | 2021 | P |
| Stingrays | Jack Ballas | Strongsville | 2021 | P, OF |
| T3 Rays | Cullen Reutter | Avon Lake | 2021 | SS, IF |
| Premier Ohio | Ty Stolarski | Medina | 2021 | SS, 2B |
| Premier Ohio | Jeff Romano | Twinsburg | 2021 | C |
| Premier Ohio | Garrett Kubitz | Brecksville | 2021 | 3B, OF |
| T3 Rays | Jake Flesher | North Ridgeville | 2021 | C, 1B |
| TEAM | NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | GRAD YR | POS |
| Andy's 9ers | Ethan Brennan | Painesville Riverside | 2021 | P, IF |
| Andy's 9ers | Riley Canitia | Mayfield | 2021 | IF, OF |
| Andy's 9ers | Ethan Kotnik | Notre Dame Cathedral Latin | 2021 | P, IF |
| Midwest Stars | Dylan Feltovich | Archbishop Hoban | 2021 | P, OF |
| Midwest Stars | Cale Marconi | Stow | 2021 | OF |
| Ohio Longhorns | Reese Larch | Twinsburg | 2021 | OF |
| Ohio Longhorns | Tyler Jackson | Louisville | 2021 | P |
| Andy's 9ers | Tim Costello | Willoughby South | 2021 | 1B, 3B |
| Mentor Cardinals | Evan Boyd | Mentor | 2021 | 2B, OF |
| Mentor Cardinals | Ethan Brown | Painesville Riverside | 2021 | 3B, 1B |
| Mentor Cardinals | Joe Malchesky | Lake Catholic | 2021 | C |
| Midwest Stars | Jeff Driefke | Olmsted Falls | 2021 | P, 1B |
| Ohio Longhorns | Jacob Mathey | Copley | 2021 | C |
| Ohio Longhorns | Peter Jelenic | Wadsworth | 2021 | SS |
| Mentor Cardinals | JR Walker | Mentor | 2021 | 1B, DH |
FIRST TEAM AMERICAN DIVISION
|
TEAM |
PLAYER NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | GRAD YR |
| Release Baseball 17u | Jake Armsey | Walsh Jesuit H.S. | 2021 |
| Gavin Bruni | Alliance H.S. | 2021 | |
| Jacob Gehring | South Range H.S. | 2021 | |
| Noah Arkenburg | |||
| Rawlings Diamond Boys Select | Jake Peebles | Wadsworth H.S. | 2020 |
| Brian Roscoe | Coventry H.S. | 2020 | |
| Todd Bangston | Walsh Univ. | 2019 | |
| Jacob Reifsnyder | Kent St. Univ. | 2019 | |
| Diamond Hit Club TA | Jake Crouch | Mayfield H.S. | 2020 |
| Tyler Horvath | Twinsburg H.S. | 2020 | |
| Ohio Longhorns JA | Tim Orr | Uniontown Lake H.S. | 2020 |
| Kyle Aten | Uniontown Lake H.S. | 2020 | |
| Zac Common | Kent Roosevelt H.S. | 2020 | |
| Hurricanes Select | Steven Hemminger | Revere H.S. | 2021 |
| Anthony Paskell | Solon H.S. | 2022 | |
| T3 Rays | Brad Lloyd | Jefferson H.S. | 2019 |
| Spencer Crane | Lake Erie College | 2019 |
FIRST TEAM NATIONAL DIVISION
| TEAM | PLAYER NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | HS GRAD YR |
| Ohio Longhorns JD | Nick Lallathin | Walsh Univ. | 2019 |
| Carl Pennington | Baldwin Wallace Univ | 2019 | |
| Aiden Samuel | Mount Union College | 2019 | |
| Layne Perks | Walsh Univ. | 2018 | |
| Stark County Terriers | JC Philippi | Malone Univ. | 2019 |
| Noah Kandel | Tiffin Univ. | 2019 | |
| Evan Swan | Ashland Univ. | 2019 | |
| Diamond Hit Club ML | Max Monachino | Wittenberg Univ. | 2019 |
| Justin Laley | Lakeland C.C. | 2019 | |
| Justin DeMassimo | Lakeland C.C. | 2019 | |
| Release Baseball 18u | Joe Horoszko | Wittenberg Univ. | 2019 |
| Dan Keenan | Sinclair C.C. | 2019 | |
| Sam Melnyk | Cuyahoga C.C. | 2019 | |
| Diamond Boys 18u | Joe Caspar | Hudson H.S. | 2020 |
| Jarrett Martin | Ashland Univ. | 2019 | |
| Akron A's Showcase | Charlie Drumm | Mount Union College | 2019 |
| Golden Spikes | Gary Ghiz | Jefferson H.S. | 2020 |
| Dominic Paolilo | Edgewood H.S. | 2020 |
SECOND TEAM AMERICAN DIVISION
| TEAM | NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | HS GRAD YR |
| Rawlings Diamond Boys Select | Landon Robinson | Copley H.S. | 2021 |
| Malcolm Nietenbach | Woodridge H.S. | 2020 | |
| Release Baseball 17u | Cole Zak | Mayfield H.S. | 2020 |
| Trey Pancake | South Range H.S. | 2021 | |
| Diamond Hit Club TA | Will Keefe | Twinsburg H.S. | 2020 |
| Matt Kahn | Twinsburg H.S. | 2020 | |
| Ohio Longhorns JA | Eden Wertz | Revere H.S. | 2020 |
| Carson Murphy | Woodridge H.S. | 2020 | |
| Hurricanes Select | Tyler Gast | Olmsted Falls H.S. | 2020 |
| Tommy Salman | St. Ignatius H.S. | 2021 | |
| Owen Desberg | Revere H.S. | 2021 | |
| T3 Rays | Emerson Tuchowski | Westlake H.S. | 2020 |
| Aaron Wrost | Brooklyn H.S. | 2020 | |
| Daniel Carbeck | 2019 |
SECOND TEAM NATIONAL DIVISION
| TEAM | NAME | SCHOOL IN FALL | HS GRAD YR |
| Ohio Longhorns JD | Matthew Amison | Walsh Univ. | 2019 |
| Jameson Campbell | Wash. & Jeff. Univ. | 2018 | |
| Stark County Terriers | Andrew Hawkins | St. Thomas Aquinas H.S. | 2020 |
| Andrew Gray | Malone Univ. | 2019 | |
| Diamond Hit Club ML | Dylan Jackson | Wittenberg Univ. | 2019 |
| Jacob Ober | 2019 | ||
| Release Baseball 18u | Anthony DiTomas | 2019 | |
| Cole Weiss | Denison Univ. | 2019 | |
| Diamond Boys 18u | Andrew Wachs | Copley H.S. | 2020 |
| Zach Naymik | Streetsboro H.S. | 2020 | |
| Andrew Caspar | Hudson H.S. | 2020 | |
| Akron A's Showcase | Chase Miller | Marietta College | 2019 |
| Zach Weaver | 2019 | ||
| Golden Spikes | Corey Razum | Mayfield H.S. | 2021 |
| Kyle Davanaugh | Notre Dame College | 2019 |
HONORABLE MENTION
| Stark County Terriers | Dalton Frey |
| Tyler Urconis | |
| Dominic Mongiardo | |
| Release Baseball 17u | Nate Kusner |
| Blake Buzzeo | |
| Michael McFadden | |
| Ohio Longhorns JA | Sylvan Wiley |
| Adam Folk | |
| Andrew Mekeal | |
| Ohio Longhorns JD | Matthew McGrath |
| Garrett Bischof | |
| Joe Toth | |
| Diamond Boys | Nate Montecalvo |
| Diamond Hit Club ML | Seth Higham |
| John Razzante | |
| Tim Munz | |
| Diamond Hit Club TA | Tyler Tierno |
| Zach Cirinci | |
| Akron A's Showcase | Mike Wunderle |
| Zack Meyerson | |