| Year | Champion | Division |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Cardinals Club | |
| 2021 | Premier Ohio Stallions KB | |
| 2020 | Release Baseball | |
| 2019 | Ohio Aces | |
| 2018 | Mentor Cardinals | |
| 2017 | Brownlee Lookouts | American Division |
| T3 Rays | National Division | |
| 2016 | Force Elite | |
| 2015 | Hurricanes Select | |
| 2014 | Northern Ohio | |
| 2013 | Lake Erie Bulldogs | |
| 2012 | Northern Ohio Hurricanes | |
| North Coast | ||
| Up To Bat Titans | ||
| 2011 | Northern Ohio Storm | |
| 2010 | Up To Bat Titans | |
| Brownlee Lookouts | ||
| 2009 | Stars Baseball | |
| Lake Erie Bulldogs | ||
| 2008 | Boys of Summer | |
| 2007 | Northern Ohio Hurricanes | |
| PB Baseball |